Management & Staff


  • President
    Steven J. Coffey
  • Chief Operating Officer
    Siobhan Davey
  • Vice President of Finance
    Ian Coffey
  • Assistant Vice President of Underwriting
    Joann Palmer
  • Claims Manager
    Robert Barnes


  • Clerical Assistant
    Amanda Kanick
  • Accounting Representative
    Rachel Mastin
  • Personal Lines Underwriter
    Kortney Bianco
  • Personal Lines Underwriter
    Colleen Gales
  • Commercial Lines Underwriter
    Valarie Casey
  • Commercial Lines Underwriter
    Kim Tait
  • Claims Representative
    Jackie Boeltz


Phone: (607) 321-2655
Toll Free: (866) 921-BCIC

Fax: (607) 321-2644

Broome Co-operative Insurance Company
1923 Vestal Parkway East
PO Box 1280
Vestal, NY 13851

Financial Standing

Broome Co-operative is rated A′ (A Prime) Unsurpassed by Demotech, Inc.

Broome Co-operative is rated B++ (Good) by AM Best.